Both these balls sit at the top of the non-tour premium range, combining soft feel, solid spin, and distinctive alignment features. The 2025 Callaway ERC Soft and the 2025 TaylorMade Tour Response Stripe come without the premium price tag.
In this head-to-head, check which one is closer to your playing style.
Comparison Overview
| Model | 2025 Callaway ERC Soft | 2025 TaylorMade Tour Response Stripe |
| Compression | Mid, softer than tour, firmer than two-piece balls | Mid, softer than tour balls |
| Feel | Mild-soft with feedback | Soft with solid feedback |
| Spin | More spin than expected, solid control | Decent greenside spin, moderate overall |
| Trajectory | High flight, straighter | High flight, consistent |
| Distance | Strong distance, can overshoot | Strong for its class, long carry |
| Durability | Very good, minimal scuffing over two rounds | Very good, light scuffs and minor paint wear |
| Ideal Golfer | Mid-handicap players wanting distance and alignment help | Mid-handicap players seeking soft feel with visual feedback |
| Price | $39.99/dozen | $45.99/dozen |
| Color Options | White, Yellow, Turvis, 360 Fade | Neon yellow, blue, pink, multi-pack, plus white/yellow versions |
Who Is Each Ball Suited For?
2025 Callaway ERC Soft
- Golfers who want a balanced performer with distance and soft feel
- Players who benefit from Triple Track alignment technology
- Mid-handicap golfers looking for control and consistency across the bag
2025 TaylorMade Tour Response Stripe
- Golfers who want premium urethane performance with enhanced visibility
- Players who enjoy alignment feedback and colorful ball designs
- Mid-handicappers seeking consistency and easy distance
Performance Comparison
Feel and Putter Feedback
- ERC Soft: Mild-soft with added feedback, balanced feel off the putter. Triple Track alignment helps with setup and roll.
- Tour Response Stripe: Softer, smoother off the putter, with clear visual feedback from the 360° alignment stripe.
EDGE: Tour Response Stripe — softer feel and more visible putting feedback.
Around the Green
- ERC Soft: Generates a bit more greenside spin than expected, solid on bump-and-runs and chips.
- Tour Response Stripe: Good greenside spin, but requires pace adjustment; overall reliable performance once dialed in.
EDGE: ERC Soft — slightly stronger and more predictable greenside control.
Approach Shots
- ERC Soft: High, straight flight with good spin balance and strong stopping power on greens
- Tour Response Stripe: High trajectory with consistent flight, solid distance, and dependable feedback.
EDGE: Tie — both offer impressive control and flight consistency for their category.
Durability
- ERC Soft: Minimal scuffing after nearly two full rounds, retains performance.
- Tour Response Stripe: Small color wear and minor marks, otherwise excellent durability.
EDGE: Tie — both durable and built to last multiple rounds.
Looks and Visibility
- ERC Soft: Clean look but busier design with Triple Track lines; helps with alignment.
- Tour Response Stripe: Bright, fun color choices with a bold 360° stripe that improves visibility.
EDGE: Tour Response Stripe — more vibrant and visually engaging on the course.
Not Sure Yet?
If you are not ready to choose, do not worry. Check the full reviews below and make the best decision for your game.
