This is the first of a series of articles on golf ball comparisons. By making these comparisons based on my reviews, I aim to assist you in selecting the best golf ball for your game. We will start with two popular models and solid performers: the 2025 Callaway Supersoft and the 2025 Srixon Soft Feel.
Both have been updated for the season and offer solid performance without the price tag of a tour ball. But which one is better for your game? The comparison is based on my reviews in real playing conditions.
Comparison Overview
| Model | 2025 Callaway Supersoft | 2025 Srixon Soft Feel |
| Compression | Very low (marshmallow soft feel) | ~58 (slightly firmer feel) |
| Feel | Extremely soft across all shots | Soft with a touch more firmness and feedback |
| Spin | Low overall, improved but not high around greens | Moderate—good short-game spin for a soft ball |
| Trajectory | High launch, good carry | Mid to high flight, more penetrating |
| Distance | Long carry, forgiving on mishits | Consistent distance, solid stopping power |
| Durability | Very good, minor marks after a full round | Excellent durability |
| Ideal Golfer | Players wanting maximum softness and higher launch | Players wanting maximum softness and a higher launch |
| Price | $24.99/dozen | $24.99/dozen |
| Color Options | White, yellow, green, orange, pink, red, splatter | White, yellow, brite green, brite orange, brite red |
Who Is Each Ball Suited For?
2025 Callaway Supersoft
- Golfers who prefer an extremely soft, almost marshmallow feel
- Players who benefit from higher launch and straighter ball flight
- Anyone who values good durability at an affordable price
2025 Srixon Soft Feel
- Golfers who like a soft feel but also want moderate greenside spin
- Players who prefer mid-to-high trajectory with more stopping power
- Those who appreciate a balanced ball that performs consistently
Performance Comparison
Feel and Putter Feedback
- Supersoft: Extremely soft feel off the putter, mellow sound, requires minimal adjustment on long putts.
- Soft Feel: Soft sensation with a bit more firmness and feedback when striking putts.
EDGE: Soft Feel—more feedback without losing softness.
Around the Green
- Supersoft: Low spin, rolls out more on chips.
- Soft Feel: Moderate spin for a two-piece ball, easier to control rollout and stopping distance.
EDGE: Soft Feel—better short-game control.
Approach Shots
- Supersoft: High flight, helps stop on softer greens, forgiving distance.
- Soft Feel: Mid-high trajectory with consistent stopping power even on firm greens.
EDGE: Soft Feel—more balanced distance and control.
Durability
- Supersoft: Very good durability, only a few marks after a round.
- Soft Feel: Excellent durability with minimal wear.
EDGE: Soft Feel—slightly tougher cover.
Looks and Visibility
- Supersoft: Wide range of bright colors and splatter options.
- Soft Feel: Classic brite color options with clean design.
EDGE: Supersoft—more variety in colors.
Not Sure Yet?
If you are not ready to choose, do not worry. Check the full reviews below and make the best decision for your game.
