This is the first of a series of articles on golf ball comparisons. By making these comparisons based on my reviews, I aim to assist you in selecting the best golf ball for your game. We will start with two popular models and solid performers: the 2025 Callaway Supersoft and the 2025 Srixon Soft Feel.
Both have been updated for the season and offer solid performance without the price tag of a tour ball. But which one is better for your game? The comparison is based on my reviews in real playing conditions.
Comparison Table
| Model | 2025 Callaway Supersoft | 2025 Srixon Soft Feel |
| Compression | Very low (marshmallow soft feel) | ~58 (slightly firmer feel) |
| Feel | Extremely soft across all shots | Soft with a touch more firmness and feedback |
| Spin | Low overall, improved but not high around greens | Moderate—good short-game spin for a soft ball |
| Trajectory | High launch, good carry | Mid to high flight, more penetrating |
| Distance | Long carry, forgiving on mishits | Consistent distance, solid stopping power |
| Durability | Very good, minor marks after a full round | Excellent durability |
| Ideal Golfer | Players wanting maximum softness and higher launch | Players wanting maximum softness and a higher launch |
| Price | $24.99/dozen | $24.99/dozen |
| Color Options | White, yellow, green, orange, pink, red, splatter | White, yellow, brite green, brite orange, brite red |
Who Is Each Ball Suited For?
2025 Callaway Supersoft
- Golfers who prefer an extremely soft, almost marshmallow feel
- Players who benefit from higher launch and straighter ball flight
- Anyone who values good durability at an affordable price
2025 Srixon Soft Feel
- Golfers who like a soft feel but also want moderate greenside spin
- Players who prefer mid-to-high trajectory with more stopping power
- Those who appreciate a balanced ball that performs consistently
Performance Comparison
Feel and Putter Feedback
- Supersoft: Extremely soft feel off the putter, mellow sound, requires minimal adjustment on long putts.
- Soft Feel: Soft sensation with a bit more firmness and feedback when striking putts.
EDGE: Soft Feel—more feedback without losing softness.
Around the Green
- Supersoft: Low spin, rolls out more on chips.
- Soft Feel: Moderate spin for a two-piece ball, easier to control rollout and stopping distance.
EDGE: Soft Feel—better short-game control.
Approach Shots
- Supersoft: High flight, helps stop on softer greens, forgiving distance.
- Soft Feel: Mid-high trajectory with consistent stopping power even on firm greens.
EDGE: Soft Feel—more balanced distance and control.
Durability
- Supersoft: Very good durability, only a few marks after a round.
- Soft Feel: Excellent durability with minimal wear.
EDGE: Soft Feel—slightly tougher cover.
Looks and Visibility
- Supersoft: Wide range of bright colors and splatter options.
- Soft Feel: Classic brite color options with clean design.
EDGE: Supersoft—more variety in colors.
Which Should You Pick?
Choose the 2025 Callaway Supersoft if:
- Want the softest possible feel on every shot
- Prefer higher launch and straighter flight
- Like having many bright color choices
Choose the 2025 Srixon Soft Feel if:
- Want soft feel with a touch more firmness and spin
- Prefer consistent stopping power on approach shots
- Value excellent durability and balanced performance
Not Sure Yet?
If you are not ready to choose, do not worry. Check the full reviews below and make the best decision for your game.
